Progestin vs. Estrogen: Impact on Hair Loss

Birth control can affect your hair health in surprising ways. Here's what you need to know:

• Progestin-only birth control (like the minipill, hormonal IUDs, or implants) may increase hair loss risk due to androgenic (male hormone-like) effects, especially in women sensitive to hormonal changes or with conditions like PCOS.
• Estrogen-containing birth control (combined pills) can help protect against hair loss by extending the hair growth phase and reducing androgens' effects.
• Women with PCOS or a family history of hair loss are at higher risk and should consider low-androgen contraceptives or non-hormonal options.
• Hair loss caused by birth control is often temporary and can be managed with treatments like oral minoxidil or topical spironolactone.

Quick Comparison

Takeaway: If you're concerned about hair loss, consult your doctor to choose the right birth control for your needs. Treatments are available to address hair thinning caused by hormonal shifts.

The TRUTH About Birth Control & Hair Loss | What's Causing Hair Loss in Women?

How Hormones Affect Hair Growth

Hair growth operates on a cycle heavily influenced by hormones. Androgens, estrogens, and progestins all play significant roles in this process, which explains why various birth control methods can impact your hair differently. To understand these effects, it’s essential to first grasp how hormone changes interact with the hair growth cycle.

Hair Growth Cycle and Hormone Changes

The hair growth cycle consists of three distinct phases:

• Anagen (growth phase): This is when hair actively grows, with approximately 85–90% of hair follicles in this stage at any given time. It lasts anywhere from 2 to 7 years, and higher levels of estrogen can prolong this phase. For example, during pregnancy, elevated estrogen levels extend the anagen phase, leading to thicker, fuller hair.
• Catagen (transition phase): About 2% of hair follicles enter this brief, two-week phase, where the follicles shrink and detach from their blood supply.
• Telogen (resting phase): Roughly 10–15% of hair follicles are in this stage, where hair stops growing and eventually sheds to make way for new growth.

Hormonal shifts - whether from birth control, PCOS, or other conditions - can disrupt this cycle. When hormones are out of balance, hair follicles may prematurely enter the telogen phase, resulting in increased shedding and noticeable thinning.

Estrogen plays a key role in extending the anagen phase by binding to receptors in hair follicles. Similarly, progesterone offers some protection by reducing the conversion of testosterone into dihydrotestosterone (DHT) at the follicle level, which can help minimize hair loss.

These hormonal interactions set the stage for understanding how androgens specifically impact scalp hair.

How Androgens Cause Hair Loss in Women

Androgens, such as testosterone, DHT, DHEAS, and androstenedione, have a complex relationship with hair. While they promote hair growth in certain areas of the body, they can have the opposite effect on the scalp. On the scalp, androgens can shrink hair follicles and shorten the growth cycle, leading to thinner, weaker hair over time.

DHT is particularly impactful. This potent androgen binds to receptors in scalp hair follicles, gradually causing them to shrink. Over time, these miniaturized follicles produce increasingly finer hair strands until growth ceases entirely.

Conditions like PCOS highlight the effects of elevated androgens. In PCOS, high androgen levels, coupled with low progesterone, insulin resistance, and reduced sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG), accelerate follicle miniaturization. This hormonal imbalance pushes more hair into the telogen phase, causing increased shedding and thinning. Insulin resistance further complicates matters, as high insulin levels stimulate additional androgen production and trigger inflammation, disrupting the hair growth cycle.

This hormonal environment often results in a distinct pattern of hair loss, typically starting with thinning at the part line and spreading outward from the crown. Additionally, certain progestin-only birth control methods, particularly those with androgenic properties, can exacerbate hair loss in women who are already susceptible.

Progestin-Only Birth Control and Hair Loss

Progestin-only contraceptives are a go-to option for women who can't or prefer not to take estrogen. Since hormones play a major role in hair growth, it's important to understand how these contraceptives might affect hair health. Progestin-only methods include the minipill, hormonal IUDs (like Mirena, Skyla, and Liletta), implants such as Norplant, and injections like Depo-Provera. While effective at preventing pregnancy, they may raise concerns when it comes to hair loss.

How Progestins Affect Hair

Here's the thing: synthetic progestins behave differently from natural progesterone. Unlike natural progesterone, which doesn’t have androgenic effects, synthetic progestins can act like androgens (male hormones). This is because their molecular structure is similar to testosterone. As a result, they can bind to hair follicle receptors on the scalp, potentially speeding up follicle miniaturization - a process linked to thinning hair. This is particularly true for first- and second-generation progestins, such as norgestrel and levonorgestrel, which have a higher androgenic potential.

When these androgenic progestins circulate in the bloodstream, they may trigger hair thinning, especially in women who are genetically predisposed to hair loss. This is why understanding the androgenic properties of progestins is crucial for women concerned about hair health.

What the Research Says About Hair Loss and Progestin-Only Methods

Studies suggest a connection between progestin-only contraceptives and an increased risk of androgenetic alopecia. One study reported that users of progestin-containing contraceptives had a 21% higher risk of hair loss compared to non-users. For hormonal IUDs, hair loss is less common - affecting between 0.33% and 11.5% of users - but it remains one of the top reasons women request IUD removal. Similarly, implants and injections, which continuously release synthetic hormones, may also expose hair follicles to prolonged androgenic effects, increasing the likelihood of hair thinning over time.

Certain groups, such as women with PCOS or a family history of hair loss, may be more vulnerable. In these cases, healthcare providers often recommend later-generation oral contraceptives with lower androgenic activity to better support hair health.

The American Hair Loss Association also weighs in, advising women with a strong family history of hair loss to consider non-hormonal birth control options. For those who prefer hormonal methods, low-androgen index pills are suggested. Additionally, some research highlights that nonhormonal IUDs or devices releasing synthetic progestins with lower androgenic activity - like etonogestrel implants or vaginal rings - may pose a smaller risk of hair loss for women who are more prone to it.

These findings underscore the importance of selecting the right contraceptive method, especially for women concerned about hair loss or those with a genetic predisposition.

Estrogen-Containing Birth Control and Hair Health

Combined oral contraceptives, which include both estrogen and progestin, create a hormonal balance that can benefit hair health. Unlike progestin-only methods, these pills are often chosen by women concerned about hair thinning or managing conditions like polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS). The estrogen component plays a key role in counteracting the effects of androgens, which can negatively impact hair growth. Let’s dive into how estrogen supports hair health beyond its contraceptive benefits.

How Estrogen Protects Against Hair Loss

In combined oral contraceptives, estrogen helps extend the hair growth phase and increases levels of sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG). SHBG binds to testosterone, reducing its impact on hair follicles. This is particularly important because testosterone and dihydrotestosterone (DHT) can shrink hair follicles, leading to thinning. By limiting the effects of these androgens, estrogen helps maintain healthier, fuller hair.

The benefits of estrogen on hair health can be seen throughout a woman’s life. During puberty, rising estradiol levels encourage hair growth. Similarly, during pregnancy, the surge in estradiol often results in thicker, fuller hair. However, the drop in estradiol postpartum can cause temporary shedding. In contrast, as estradiol levels decline during menopause, many women notice increased thinning and dryness.

Using Combined Pills for PCOS Hair Loss

For women with PCOS, combined oral contraceptives offer specific advantages. These pills are commonly prescribed to address irregular periods, reduce elevated androgen levels, and manage hair loss - a concern affecting 40–70% of women with PCOS. Pills that include anti-androgenic progestogens, like drospirenone, are particularly effective at lowering testosterone levels and may promote hair growth.

Dr. Walter Futterweit highlights the importance of controlling androgen overproduction before addressing its effects on hair follicles. He advises using low-androgen combined pills, such as Desogen, Ortho-Cept, or Ortho-Cyclen, for managing PCOS-related hair loss.

It’s worth noting that individual responses to combined pills can vary. While many women notice improvements in hair health, others may require additional treatments, such as spironolactone, to achieve the best results. Clinics like Oana Health specialize in personalized care, helping women find the most suitable treatment plan based on their hormonal profiles and medical history.

Temporary changes in hair growth are common when starting combined pills, but these symptoms usually stabilize and improve after a few months of consistent use.

sbb-itb-6dba428

Progestin vs. Estrogen: Direct Comparison

When choosing birth control, it's important to consider how its hormonal effects might influence hair health. The main distinction lies in how progestin and estrogen impact androgen levels and, consequently, hair follicles.

Progestin-only contraceptives can carry a higher risk of hair thinning due to their androgenic properties, which may affect individuals prone to hair loss. On the other hand, estrogen-containing contraceptives help counteract androgens by increasing SHBG (sex hormone-binding globulin) levels, which reduces testosterone’s effect on hair follicles. This creates a clear difference in how these methods may influence hair health.

The American Hair Loss Association offers this advice: "To minimize the risk of hair loss, the AHLA recommends that women interested in using oral contraceptives for contraception opt for low-androgen index birth control pills". This highlights the varying risks between progestin-only and estrogen-containing options.

Comparison Table: Progestin vs. Estrogen Effects

These distinctions are crucial for both patients and healthcare providers when selecting a contraceptive that aligns with hair health priorities. For instance, a Finnish study involving over 17,000 hormonal IUD users (progestin-only) revealed that 16% reported scalp hair loss. Similarly, among 536 Depo shot users, up to 11% experienced hair thinning within the first nine months.

Those with conditions like androgenic alopecia, PCOS, or heightened sensitivity to hormonal shifts may be especially susceptible to hair thinning with progestin-only methods. While hair changes with combined pills often stabilize over time, progestin-only options can trigger earlier thinning. If you notice hair thinning while on hormonal contraception, telehealth platforms like Oana Health can help craft a personalized care plan. Their licensed professionals can prescribe treatments, such as oral minoxidil or topical spironolactone, to address hair concerns without requiring a switch in contraceptive methods.

Managing Hair Loss While Using Birth Control

You don’t have to choose between effective birth control and keeping your hair healthy. Hair loss associated with hormonal contraception is typically temporary. It can happen while you're on the pill or shortly after stopping it. Women with a family history of hair loss should be particularly mindful of this potential side effect. Pinpointing the cause of hair thinning is key to finding the right solution. Once you’ve identified the issue, there are steps you can take to prevent or address it.

Ways to Prevent or Reduce Hair Loss

One way to reduce the risk of hair loss is by switching to lower-androgenic birth control pills, such as those containing norgestimate, desogestrel, or drospirenone. According to the American Hair Loss Association (AHLA):

"To minimize the risk of hair loss, the AHLA recommends that women interested in using oral contraceptives for contraception opt for low-androgen index birth control pills. However, for those with a strong predisposition for genetic hair loss in their family, the AHLA advises considering non-hormonal forms of birth control."

Combined pills can offer additional protection because the estrogen they contain helps counteract the androgenic effects that contribute to hair loss. One way this happens is by raising levels of sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG), which lowers testosterone’s impact on hair follicles. For women especially sensitive to hormonal changes, non-hormonal options like the copper IUD may be a better fit.

Keeping tabs on your hair’s health is another useful strategy. Apps like Clue can help you monitor changes in your hair and skin when starting a new birth control method. This information can be invaluable for healthcare providers. While it’s normal to lose 50 to 100 hairs daily, tracking unusual patterns can help differentiate between regular shedding and hair loss linked to contraception. If needed, you can explore options like over-the-counter minoxidil, supplements, or low-level laser therapy to address deficiencies. And if switching contraception doesn’t resolve the issue, professional treatments are available.

Getting Hair Loss Treatment Through Telehealth

Telehealth has made it easier than ever to tackle hair loss, including cases tied to birth control. Hair thinning affects roughly one-third of women who are genetically predisposed to it, with about 30 million women in the U.S. experiencing this issue. Through telehealth platforms, you can now access specialized care for both contraceptive-related hair loss and underlying hormonal imbalances.

For example, Oana Health offers personalized hair loss treatments through its telehealth services. Their science-backed solutions are prescribed by licensed medical professionals and include options like oral minoxidil starting at $25 per month and topical spironolactone for $43 per month. Oral minoxidil promotes systemic hair regrowth, while topical spironolactone targets androgen receptors in the scalp to reduce hair thinning without significant side effects.

Combination treatments are particularly effective for women dealing with PCOS-related hair loss. Studies show that about 30% of women with PCOS experience hair thinning, making them more than twice as likely to face this issue compared to women without PCOS. Oana Health’s approach might include spironolactone for $14 per month alongside other hormonal therapies to address multiple aspects of PCOS at once.

Telehealth offers several benefits for managing hair loss. Treatments are shipped directly to your home with free delivery, and ongoing monitoring allows providers to adjust your plan as needed - all without frequent in-person visits. Research shows that treatments like minoxidil can deliver noticeable results: in a study of women aged 18–45 with mild to moderate hair loss, 19% reported moderate hair growth after eight months of use, compared to just 7% in the placebo group. This highlights the importance of using proven treatments under the guidance of qualified healthcare professionals.

Conclusion: Main Points

Estrogen plays a key role in promoting hair growth, particularly by stimulating hair follicles during the anagen phase, which leads to thicker and longer hair. This explains why many women notice their hair becomes fuller during pregnancy, when estrogen levels are at their highest, and why menopause, with its drop in estrogen, often results in thinning hair. For women with a family history of hair loss, combined birth control pills containing estrogen are often a better option for hair health compared to progestin-only pills.

On the other hand, synthetic progestins can contribute to hair loss, especially in women who are hormonally sensitive. Unlike natural progesterone - which helps reduce the conversion of testosterone to DHT (a hormone linked to hair thinning) - synthetic progestins may actually promote hair loss. This difference is crucial when selecting contraceptive methods and understanding how hormonal birth control can impact hair.

Given these nuances, professional guidance is essential. As Dr. Viktoryia Kazlouskaya, a board-certified dermatologist, advises:

"Regular monitoring of your progress is important, and working closely with a specialist ensures that you can track changes effectively."

Healthcare providers can help pinpoint the cause of hair loss and suggest tailored solutions. These might include switching to a lower-androgenic birth control method or exploring targeted hair loss treatments.

For accessible treatment options, telehealth platforms like Oana Health offer personalized solutions such as oral minoxidil for $25/month and topical spironolactone for $43/month. These treatments, prescribed by licensed professionals and shipped directly to your home, make it easier to address both contraceptive-related hair loss and hormonal imbalances like PCOS.

Hair loss caused by hormonal contraception is often temporary, but early consultation is critical. With the right support and treatment, it’s possible to maintain effective birth control while keeping your hair healthy.

FAQs

How can I tell if my birth control is causing hair loss, and what should I do about it?

If you’ve started experiencing more hair thinning or shedding after going on birth control, the hormones in the medication might be playing a role. Some birth control pills, particularly those containing progestin, can have androgenic properties. This means they might contribute to hair loss, especially if you’re already genetically prone to it.

The first step is to talk to your healthcare provider. They can help identify whether your birth control is the culprit and might suggest switching to another type, adjusting your dosage, or considering non-hormonal alternatives. It’s also crucial to rule out other possible reasons for hair loss, such as stress, nutrient deficiencies, or underlying health issues. Your provider can offer advice on treatments or lifestyle adjustments that may promote healthier hair growth.

How do progestin-only and estrogen-containing birth control methods affect hair health differently?

Progestin-only birth control is more likely to lead to hair loss because progestin can cause telogen effluvium - a condition where hair follicles enter the shedding phase prematurely. Unlike estrogen, progestin doesn't offer the same protective effects for hair. Estrogen supports hair growth by maintaining the anagen phase (the growth phase) of the hair cycle, which is essential for healthy hair.

On the other hand, contraceptives that include estrogen might actually promote better hair health. They can help balance out the androgenic effects of certain progestins, making them a better choice for those who are sensitive to hormonal changes or have a family history of hair loss. If you're noticing hair loss or have concerns about how birth control might impact your hair, speaking with a healthcare provider can help you find the best option for your needs.

What birth control options are best for women with PCOS or a family history of hair loss?

For women dealing with PCOS or a family history of hair loss, selecting the right birth control comes down to individual health priorities and concerns. If androgenic symptoms, like hair loss or excess hair growth, aren’t an issue, progestin-only options such as the Mirena IUD or Depo-Provera might be a good fit. However, for those looking to address PCOS-related challenges like acne, irregular cycles, or hormonal imbalances, combined hormonal contraceptives (CHCs) that include both estrogen and progestin could be more effective.

Because everyone’s health needs are unique, it’s crucial to consult with a healthcare provider. This ensures you choose an option that aligns with your hormonal health and overall well-being.

Related posts

• Minoxidil for PCOS Hair Loss: What to Expect Long-Term
• Stress and PCOS Hair Loss: What to Know
• Birth Control and Hair Loss: What You Need to Know
• Hair Loss and Injectable Birth Control: What to Know